Cookie Banners and Privacy Policies: What Pennsylvania and New Jersey Businesses Actually Need in 2026
Nathaniel Kober · · 10 min read
Part of our Government & Municipal Services work.
Most small business websites in Pennsylvania and New Jersey don't legally need a cookie banner, but almost all of them need an accurate privacy policy. Here's what New Jersey's privacy law requires, where Pennsylvania's bill stands, why wiretap lawsuits matter, and what to put on your site.
Article
Cookie banners went up on websites everywhere over the past few years, often because a plugin offered one or a competitor had one. Some of those banners do real work. Many are decoration, and a few make things worse.
The short answer: no Pennsylvania or New Jersey law requires a small business to show a cookie banner. Almost every business website does need an accurate privacy policy, though, because California's privacy law reaches any site that collects personal information from California residents, and tools like Google Analytics require one in their terms. New Jersey's Data Privacy Act adds real duties for larger data handlers, including honoring browser opt-out signals. Pennsylvania doesn't have a comprehensive privacy law yet, but a bill is moving and the state's wiretap law is already driving lawsuits over tracking pixels and session recording. What matters most isn't the banner. It's knowing what your site collects, where it goes, and saying so honestly.
This is general information, not legal advice. If you handle sensitive data or large volumes of customer data, talk to a privacy attorney.
The laws that actually touch a PA or NJ website
There's no single privacy law for websites in the U.S. Instead, a handful of state and federal rules overlap. Here are the ones that matter for a local business, nonprofit or borough in our area.
| Rule | Who it covers | What it requires | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| New Jersey Data Privacy Act | Organizations that handle personal data of 100,000+ NJ residents a year, or 25,000+ if they earn anything from selling data. Nonprofits are not exempt; government bodies are. | A clear privacy notice, opt-outs for targeted ads and data sales, honoring browser opt-out signals, opt-in consent for sensitive data, and responding to access and deletion requests | In effect since January 15, 2025. Opt-out signals required since July 15, 2025. |
| Pennsylvania HB 78 (proposed) | As amended in the Senate, organizations handling data of 100,000+ consumers | Similar rights to New Jersey's: opt-out of targeted ads, correction, deletion and data minimization | Not law. Passed the House in October 2025; amended in a Senate committee in June 2026; still awaiting a final Senate vote. |
| California Online Privacy Protection Act | Any commercial website that collects personal information from California residents, wherever the business is located | A posted privacy policy covering what you collect, who you share it with, how you handle Do Not Track signals, and its effective date | In effect since 2004 |
| Pennsylvania Wiretap Act | Anyone who intercepts a communication without the consent of everyone involved | Courts are deciding whether pixels, chat tools and session recording count as interception; consent and disclosure are central defenses | Active litigation |
| FTC Act | Nearly every business | Your privacy policy has to match what you actually do | In effect |
New Jersey: a real privacy law, with thresholds
New Jersey's Data Privacy Act took effect on January 15, 2025. It doesn't apply to everyone. It covers organizations that, in a year, control or process the personal data of at least 100,000 New Jersey residents, not counting data used only to complete a payment, or at least 25,000 residents if they get any revenue or discount from selling personal data.
Two details catch people off guard:
- Nonprofits aren't exempt. Many state privacy laws skip nonprofits. New Jersey's largely doesn't, so a large charity, membership group or league with a big New Jersey list should check the numbers. State agencies and local governments are exempt.
- Browser opt-out signals count. Since July 15, 2025, covered organizations must honor a universal opt-out signal, such as Global Privacy Control, as a request to opt out of targeted advertising and data sales. A visitor whose browser sends that signal shouldn't have to click anything on your site.
The law also requires opt-in consent before processing sensitive data, which in New Jersey includes financial information, and a privacy notice that explains what you collect, why, who you share it with, and how people can exercise their rights and appeal a decision.
Enforcement belongs to the Division of Consumer Affairs, with penalties of up to $10,000 for a first violation and $20,000 for later ones under the Consumer Fraud Act. There's no private right to sue. Early on, the Division could offer a 30-day window to fix a problem before acting, but that grace period ended on July 15, 2026.
One loose end: the Division proposed detailed rules in June 2025, but they weren't adopted within a year and expired on June 2, 2026. The law itself is fully in force. Only the extra detail the rules would have added is in limbo.
Pennsylvania: no privacy law yet, but a bill is close
Pennsylvania doesn't have a comprehensive consumer privacy law. House Bill 78, the Consumer Data Privacy Act, passed the House 127 to 76 on October 1, 2025. A Senate committee amended it in June 2026, including raising the coverage threshold from 50,000 to 100,000 consumers, and it has been awaiting a final Senate vote since. If the Senate passes it, the House would still need to agree to the changes before it reached the governor, and the bill would take effect a year after it becomes law.
For most small businesses, a 100,000-consumer threshold means the bill wouldn't apply directly. It's still worth watching, because privacy laws tend to set expectations that customers, vendors and platforms pick up regardless of who is technically covered.
The Pennsylvania risk most people don't know about: the Wiretap Act
The bigger near-term issue in Pennsylvania isn't a privacy statute. It's the state's Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Control Act, which bars intercepting a communication without the consent of everyone involved.
Plaintiffs have argued that tools many websites use, such as session replay scripts that record clicks and keystrokes, advertising pixels and some chat widgets, intercept visitors' communications and send them to third parties without consent. In a 2022 case, Popa v. Harriet Carter Gifts, the federal appeals court covering Pennsylvania held that the interception happens at the visitor's browser, which keeps these cases tied to Pennsylvania. More recently, the same court dismissed several of these suits because plaintiffs couldn't show a concrete harm from ordinary browsing, including a March 2026 ruling in the Popa case itself. That's helpful for businesses, but it hasn't closed the door: similar claims may still go forward in state court, and the statute allows damages of $100 a day or $1,000, whichever is higher, plus attorney's fees.
The practical lesson is that consent and disclosure are the main defenses. Courts have looked at privacy policies and consent banners when deciding whether visitors agreed to be tracked.
So, do you need a cookie banner?
Under U.S. law, usually not. Most state privacy laws, New Jersey's included, are opt-out laws: you can generally collect ordinary data without asking first, as long as you explain it and give people a working way to say no to targeted ads and data sales. A banner is one way to deliver that, not a requirement in itself.
A banner starts to make sense when:
- You run advertising pixels or session recording. A clear notice and choice before those tools load is your best evidence of consent if a wiretap claim ever comes up.
- You're covered by New Jersey's law and use targeted advertising, and you want an obvious opt-out alongside honoring browser signals.
- You serve visitors in Europe or the U.K. Those laws require opt-in consent before non-essential cookies, and U.S. thresholds don't change that.
What you shouldn't do is put up a banner that doesn't do anything. A "Reject" button that still lets the pixels fire is worse than no banner at all, because it's a promise your site breaks every time someone clicks it.
Why this is about trust, not just compliance
Privacy researcher Helen Nissenbaum describes privacy as contextual integrity: people share information with an expectation about where it will go, based on the setting they shared it in. Someone who fills out your quote form expects you to call them back. They don't expect their visit, what they typed and which pages they lingered on to be sent to an advertising network.
That's why the trouble usually isn't the data itself. It's the gap between what visitors reasonably expect and what quietly happens in the background. Closing that gap, by collecting less and explaining clearly, is what keeps customers' trust. The law is catching up to the same idea.
Almost everyone needs a privacy policy
Even if no state privacy law covers your business, you very likely need a privacy policy:
- California's CalOPPA applies to any commercial website that collects personal information, like a name or email address on a contact form, from California residents, no matter where the business is located.
- Google Analytics' terms require sites that use it to have a privacy policy, and most advertising platforms have similar rules.
- The FTC treats a privacy policy that misdescribes your practices as deceptive. A policy copied from another site, or one that hasn't been updated since your last redesign, is a real risk.
What your privacy policy should cover
- What personal information you collect: forms, email signups, orders, cookies and analytics.
- Why you collect it and how you use it.
- Which outside services receive it, such as your email platform, analytics, ad networks, payment processor or chat tool.
- Whether you sell personal data or use it for targeted ads, and how to opt out.
- How you respond to Do Not Track and Global Privacy Control signals.
- How people can ask to see, correct or delete their information, and how to appeal.
- How you'll announce changes, plus an effective date.
- A way to contact you about privacy.
Audit your site's tracking first
A privacy policy is only as accurate as your knowledge of the site. Before writing or updating one, list:
- Every analytics tool (Google Analytics, tag managers, heatmaps).
- Every advertising pixel (Meta, Google Ads, LinkedIn, TikTok).
- Session replay or recording tools.
- Chat widgets and booking tools.
- Embedded content that sets its own cookies, like YouTube videos, maps and social feeds.
- Forms, and where their submissions go.
Then remove anything nobody uses. Every tool you delete is one less thing to disclose and one less place data can leak.
What about boroughs and townships?
New Jersey's law exempts state agencies and local governments, and Pennsylvania's bill is aimed at businesses. That doesn't mean a municipal website can ignore privacy. Residents expect even more care from their local government than from a store, and a borough site loaded with advertising pixels is hard to justify. The same audit applies: know what's on the site, keep only what serves residents, and explain it plainly.
How we handle it
When we build or take over a site, we review the analytics, pixels, chat tools and embeds it's running and remove what isn't being used. We write privacy policies from what the site actually does, rather than from a generic template, and update them when tools change. When a client runs advertising pixels or serves visitors who are covered by New Jersey's law, we set up consent and opt-out tools that actually control those scripts, and we test them before launch. For anything involving sensitive data or large customer lists, we recommend the client have a privacy attorney review the final policy.
Frequently asked questions
Does my website legally need a cookie banner in Pennsylvania or New Jersey?
No law in either state requires a cookie banner as such. New Jersey's Data Privacy Act requires covered organizations to offer opt-outs and honor browser opt-out signals, and a banner is one way to do that. Sites with European visitors, or that run advertising pixels or session recording, have stronger reasons to use one.
Does New Jersey's privacy law apply to my small business?
Only if you handle the personal data of at least 100,000 New Jersey residents a year, or at least 25,000 if you earn any revenue from selling personal data. Most small local businesses fall below those numbers, but nonprofits are not exempt.
Does Pennsylvania have a consumer privacy law?
Not yet. House Bill 78 passed the House in October 2025 and was amended in a Senate committee in June 2026, but as of November 2026 it hasn't received a final Senate vote. If enacted, it would take effect a year later.
Do I need a privacy policy if I only have a contact form?
Very likely, yes. California's CalOPPA applies to commercial websites that collect personal information from California residents regardless of where the business is, and a contact form collects names and email addresses. Google Analytics and most ad platforms also require one.
What is Global Privacy Control?
It's a signal a visitor's browser sends to say they don't want their data sold or used for targeted advertising. New Jersey and a number of other states require covered businesses to treat it as a valid opt-out.
Related reading
- Who regulates your website? A 2026 guide for Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
- How to write an accessibility statement.
- The digital divide in 2026.
- Choosing a web agency: 10 questions to ask before you sign.
Sources
- Baker Donelson, Consumer Data Privacy Law Guide: New Jersey.
- Akin Gump, New Jersey Data Protection Act: What Businesses Need to Know.
- Troutman Pepper Locke, New Jersey's Proposed Data Privacy Regulations Have Expired (June 2026).
- Pennsylvania General Assembly, House Bill 78, 2025–2026 Regular Session.
- US Privacy Atlas, Pennsylvania Consumer Data Privacy Act (HB 78).
- Altoona Mirror, Consumer privacy bill edges closer to governor's desk (June 2026).
- Termageddon, Guide to CalOPPA.
- Fisher Phillips, Another Digital Wiretapping Win Is Good News for Businesses (April 2026).
- Open Class Actions, WESCA: Pennsylvania Wiretap Act.
- CookieChimp, How US States Handle Cookie Banners.
- Helen Nissenbaum, Privacy in Context: Technology, Policy, and the Integrity of Social Life (Stanford University Press, 2010).
Images in this post are AI-generated illustrations.